Stores like Brandy Melville: 8 places to shop the same look

Young woman in a white crop top and jeans

Brandy Melville sells a small range of basics in mostly one size: baby tees, tiny cardigans, pleated skirts, sweatpants. The look is simple, the colors are muted, and the clothes are cheap. If one-size sizing does not work for you, or you want something similar from a brand you can find in more places, these are the stores to try.

Subdued

Subdued is an Italian brand with the same casual, slightly preppy style aimed at teens and young women. Unlike Brandy, it offers several sizes. It ships to many countries from its own webshop.

PacSun

PacSun has long stocked John Galt, Brandy Melville’s own label. That makes it the easiest way to get the actual Brandy look in a mall store. PacSun’s own women’s line covers the same baggy jeans and fitted tees.

Garage

The Canadian chain Garage sells fitted tops, mini skirts and low-rise jeans at similar prices, in standard sizes from XXS up. It has stores across Canada and in the US.

Princess Polly

Princess Polly, from Australia, is trendier than Brandy, with more party tops and mini dresses. Its basics section, though, is very close in style, and its US distribution center keeps shipping times reasonable.

Hollister

Hollister has moved toward the same muted, laid-back look in recent years. Its sweats, rib tank tops and loose jeans are close substitutes, and the size range is much wider than Brandy’s.

Urban Outfitters

Urban Outfitters sells its own BDG denim and a lot of small-label basics. Expect to pay a little more, with more variety in return.

Edikted

Edikted is an online store with crop tops, cardigans and mini skirts in the same spirit, at prices close to Brandy’s. Sizes run from XS to XL.

Aritzia

For a more grown-up version of the look, Aritzia’s in-house brands such as TNA and Wilfred make better-quality basics. It is the most expensive store here.

Why people look for alternatives

The main reason is sizing. Brandy’s one-size approach leaves many customers out, and the brand has drawn criticism for it, including in the 2024 documentary Brandy Hellville & the Cult of Fast Fashion. The stores above make the same kind of clothes in regular size ranges.

Questions about stores like Brandy Melville

What brand is closest to Brandy Melville?

Subdued and John Galt at PacSun come closest in style and price.

Is Brandy Melville really one size?

Most items are labeled one size, which in practice fits roughly an XS or S. A few items, such as some jeans, come in more sizes.

More brand alternatives

Written by Graphicly Editorial Team

The Graphicly editorial team writes about brands, the stores behind them and the alternatives worth knowing. Every article is checked by editor-in-chief Jan Willem Beumer before it is published.